Sunday
Mar072010
Iran: Senior Reformist Amani "We Have Not Decided to Remain Silent"
Sunday, March 7, 2010 at 10:55 
Shahrbanou Amani, the speaker of House of Iran's Political Parties (a supervisory body over all Iranian parties) and former lawmaker, interviewed by Khabar Online:KHABAR: Why have the reformists had no voice? Their leaders do not comment on the latest problems raised in the country and do not take a transparent stance. Is it a strategy?
AMANI: We have not opted for that. You see, whenever the ground is prepared, the reformists show an enthusiasm to express their ideas. In my view as our society has become so tense, those who are prime firebrands of such tensions have even targeted sensible Principlists as well, the figures who have served the country but are under the threat of elimination. [They do this] since those who hold the power, do not bear any voice except the echo of their own voice.
Furthermore ,when the clashes are intensified, the toleration for hearing the voice of truth, logic, and ideas based on knowledge shrinks. Currently the universities are among the rare places where the reformists can articulate their ideas.
KHABAR: What is the key problem of the reformists in conveying their ideas?
AMANI: One of the key problems is that we don't have a mass media. What can the reformists do? They don't have access to visual and aural media. No TV and radio channel is allocated to voice their ideas; even among several TV channels, none will give them just one hour to make their suggestions.
One of the issues discussed among our reformist friends (and once more I underline that it's not an organizational option) is that we prefer to express our opinions by local media. When the spouses of the post-election detainees are interviewed by foreign media, they [the spouses] say we made our utmost effort to voice our concerns through Iranian media, but they didn't allow us to do so.
On the other hand, the media serving the rival group has adopted a selective approach, censoring parts of the interviews and articles. For example on the "2030" news program aired by state TV, the programmers broadcast the parts of the items which may serve their goals. They are not faithful to the entire material.
It's not a new tactic adopted by IRIB (Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting) and other state-funded media. In several consecutive years, they have tried to eliminate one of the main Iranian political currents, which ironically has played an important role in the Islamic Republic's campaigns and suffered many tortures in the course of the revolution.
KHABAR: You said you are not allowed access to the media. Actually the reformists say we are deprived of the public forum, but they convey their ideas through the international media including Farsi-language ones. The influence of such media is undeniable, since some accuse local media, including IRIB, of following a biased strategy against the government critics. For the same reason, some are under the influence of foreign media.
AMANI: Actually right now the Green Movement and reformists are deprived of a public forum. Even at the late presidential election in June, we didn't have access to that. Some say how people joined [us] for the election. I would say because the round-the-clock trips made by many reformists and Principlists who campaigned for the other candidates except Mr. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad were greeted by people. Many of them [campaigners] are reputable people who selflessly devoted themselves to the country during the "sacred defense" (the eight-year Iraq-Iran war).
The key problem of the reformists was their limited face-to-face communication with people. Also their campaign was begun rather late. Mr. Mohammad Khatami [former President] walked out of the election and Mr. Mir Hossein Mousavi [former Prime Minister] accepted running for the Presidency rather late.
Reader Comments (6)
Scott,
Thank you for posting this interview at the eve of 8 March, the International Women's Day.
Ms Amani's remarks are revealing, especially the following sentence: "In my view as our society has become so tense, those who are prime firebrands of such tensions have even targeted sensible Principlists as well, the figures who have served the country but are under the threat of elimination."
Nevertheless I wonder, why the Reformists do not use the internet for spreading their ideas. If they were really convinced of them, they even would accept prosecution and detainment, but obviously it is more comfortable to bow to the system and stay safe.
Perhaps the Reformists should follow the example of Ayatollah Kazemeyni Boroujerdi, detained since 2006, who has sent a strong message in defence of women's rights from prison. Fortunately it is available on VOA (min. 48.23): http://bit.ly/4KYrQD
Ayatollah Boroujerdi (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hossein_Kazemeyni_Boroujerdi) is also the only Iranian cleric, who has signed the manifesto of Secular Iranian Greens: http://www.seculargreens.com/main_article2.htm
Arshama
Pretty bold for Khabar! Very interesting that the interviewer doesn't really even try to refute Amani, but rather mostly lays the groundwork for her to express her opinions (sort of like a Mousavi "interview" on Kaleme.)
Kevin Scott,
Have watched Khabar Online (eng) closely for 3 or 4 months. Previous to that, they published typical hardline articles. Then, out of the blue, they started publishing only 1 or 2 articles per day, interview format a lot, where the interviewee roasts the regime in careful language.
Mixed in with the interviews, articles revealing embarrassing regime predicaments, but in a backhanded sort of way. Once they talked about the reform movement, quoted leaders, without the slightest hint of slapdown. They are also critical, from a 'business' point of view, of the subsidy plans, unrestrained imports, lots of stuff.
I don't see any 'archives' on the English site, so over time, articles are no longer available, I guess. Check it out: http://www.khabaronline.ir/service-73.aspx
Have been told it's Speaker Larijani's voice, who knows!
PS for Kevin Scott,
Am in error, the articles remain online, but without links to them. Some examples from earlier dates:
http://www.khabaronline.ir/news-26242.aspx
Energy Minister acts as political defender
http://www.khabaronline.ir/news-26603.aspx
The Government Receives Taxes from Itself
http://www.khabaronline.ir/news-27953.aspx
Replacing Iran's nuclear negotiators will be helpful
and so on ....
Over time, seems like the content becomes more direct.
Good stuff as per usual, thanks. I do hope this kind of thing gets more exposure. uqzulh uqzulh - moncler doudoune uk.
Venice resident Rhonda DeVictor said she noticed the empty lot when she first moved into the neighborhood 12 years ago tsthlv tsthlv - mulberry alexa uk.