On Monday, speaking to the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that Syria had dropped its precondition (withdrawing from the Golan Heights) to continue talks. According to Netanyahu, Damascus’s message was conveyed by French President Nicholas Sarkozy.
Netanyahu said: “When I met with Sarkozy, he told me that the Syrians are ready to drop the precondition, but they do not want direct negotiations. Rather, they want talks through mediation.”
However, Sarkozy allegedly told Netanyahu that the Syrians want to continue peace talks only under Turkish mediation.
Is French President Nicolas Sarkozy stepping in as the “honest broker” for Israel-Syria talks? In Saudi Arabia for a two-day visit, Sarkozy — who has just met with Syrian President Bashir al-Assad and Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu in separate meetings — said: “The deadlock that we find ourselves in today is very worrying. I told both Assad and Netanyahu that France is ready to facilitate a restart of the talks if both parties thought we could help in this effort.”
Meanwhile, French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner was in Amman on Tuesday for talks with Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas. On Wednesday, he is going to Israel to hold a meeting on the prospect of peace talks.
On Friday, Syrian President Bashar al-Assad was in Paris and held a meeting with French President Nicholas Sarkozy. Assad dismissed direct talks with Israel but reiterated his country’s position that “Syria is ready to talk to Israel under the mediation of Turkey.” Assad said:
If Mr. Netanyahu is serious, he can send his teams of experts, we will send our teams of experts to Turkey. They can then talk, if they are really interested in peace.
Assad was trying to convert Paris’s willingness to be a mediator into a stimulus to encourage Israel to start peace talks in Ankara. However, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu created trouble for Turkey. On Sunday, Netanyahu said:
Israel is prepared to hold negotiations without precondition with the Syrians. I prefer direct talks, but if [they are] with a mediator then it must be fair. The Turkish prime minister [Recep Tayyip Erdogan] has not strengthened his image as an objective, fair mediator.
If France is willing to serve as mediator, Israel would be willing.
Sarkozy is trying both to fix France’s relationship with Israel and to gain a leverage by playing as a mediator in the Middle East; Assad’s manoeuvres could not save Erdogan this time! So, how are Assad and Erdogan going to behave now Sarkozy has the power to dynamize the peace talks between Israel and Palestine? The next moves are vitally important.
After the conversation, an Abbas aide told Agence France Presse, “President Sarkozy had very important suggestions on how to move the peace process forward,” without elaborating further. Another Palestinian senior official told AFP that both leaders talked about the idea of organizing a Middle East peace conference in Moscow, an idea Russia has been pushing for months.
The joint statement issued after the meeting called on Israeli and Arab sides to revive the peace process, underlined international efforts to stop Iran’s nuclear programme, and mentioned efforts for peace negotiations with Syria. Netanyahu again stated that Israel was prepared for immediate discussions as long as there are no preconditions.
Two days after Netanyahu’s visit, Syrian President Bashar Assad arrives in Paris. Although Paris has not confirmed a link between the two events, Sarkozy may be serving as the broker for a start-up of indirect talks between Syria and Israel. And that is probably the main reason for the friendliness and handshakes on Wednesday.
I think this visit will turn out to have been very important.
It was a very focused and very positive conversation. This conversation dealt with the range of subjects that are important for the security of Israel, and for our joint efforts to advance peace.
Now Netanyahu has to prepare himself for an unexpected difficulty as he meets French President Nicholas Sarkozy on Wednesday. Before the Prime Minister’s arrival, French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner harshly criticized Israel. Kouchner, who canceled his visit to Israel last month, declared that Israel was not the side demanding peace since there has been no advance on the settlement issue:
What really hurts me, and this shocks us, is that before there used to be a great peace movement in Israel. There was a left that made itself heard and a real desire for peace.
It seems to me, and I hope that I am completely wrong, that this desire has completely vanished, as though people no longer believe in it.
The criticism is undoubtedly linked to Kouchner’s announcement that he will visit the region in coming days to persuade Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas to run for re-election.
On Thursday, Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit said that he would not attend a meeting of Mediterranean Union foreign ministers if his Israeli counterpoart Avigdor Lieberman is present.
The Mediterranean Union was formed in 2008 on the initiative of French President Nicholas Sarkozy to establish economic and political connections between Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East. As well as the 27 members of the European Union, there are represenatives from Egypt, Turkey, the Palestinian Authority, Israel, Jordan, Lebanon, Croatia, Albania, Bosnia Herzegovina, Mauritania, Monaco, Montenegro, Morocco, Syria, and Tunisia.
Israel is trying to modify Egypt’s position with pressure through several countries including France. So far, however, there has been no response from Cairo.
Israel has another problem. The next venue for the Union is in Istanbul on November 24-25, and after the cancellation of the “international” military exercises, Israel is not on the best of terms with Turkey.