Tuesday's Mass Killing in Afghanistan: US Military Begins The Lying

All day we've been following reports of the mass killing in a US airstrike in western Afghanistan. The aerial assault was called in after fighting between Afghan forces, backed by coalition troops, and insurgents. Estimates of the dead have varied from a few dozen to 120 --- an accurate count may not be possible because some of the dead have already been buried --- but the provincial governor fears about 100 civilians have been killed.

US officials quickly took the official line that any civilian deaths were regrettable but were at the hands of the Taliban. A fine example of that deflection of blame can be heard in the BBC interview of the American ambassador to NATO this morning (about 1:50:00 into the podcast).

Leaving aside the consequence that relatives of dead civilians are just as likely to blame the Americans who killed them as they are the Taliban, what is already disconcerting is the US attempt to cover up the scale of the tragedy. The US military says that it has "preliminarily concluded that about 11 civilians were wounded and that 11 insurgents were killed".

How do I know that is a blatant lie? Well, because International Committee of the Red Cross officials have seen "dozens of people, including women and children" dead at the scene. The ICRC head of delegation in Kabul confirmed, "Those killed included an Afghan Red Crescent volunteer and 13 members of his family who had been sheltering from fighting in a house that was bombed in an airstrike."

None of this, of course, is to absolve the insurgents of responsibility, giving the proximity of civilians to the fighting. Still, as Afghan President Karzai is in Washington for talks, this is already a glaring example of how the Obama policy in Afghanistan will be undone not only by US military action, but by the attempts to cover up the consequences of those actions.